Discussion in 'other anti-malware software' started by anderb, Jun 5, 2007.
Hello friends I´ve heard these two softwares are the best but which is lighter?
Thanks for your help
well i wouldnt reccomend anyone to buy spysweeper after ive had problems with lots of blue screens of death and this article
spyware doctor isnt to bad an app.
dono how light the lastest version is thou.
i wont surgest anyother products just yet.
I recommend Spy Sweeper over Spy Doctor. It loads much faster and scans faster than Spy Doctor. I have had no problems with it at all. In addition PC Tools which supplies Spy Doctor sets you up for automatic renewal by default when you purchase a product from them so you must be very careful when buying anything from them.
Thank you for the link, very interesting reading... I wonder what is the situation now at webroot....
Although both products offer many active protections and have excellent detection rates:
1. Spysweeper is just bloated. Slowed down my PC too much.
2. Spyware Doctor gives MANY false positives. So don't install unless you like being scared once a month with a false alarm. I believe it's active protection is superior to Webroot. It's detection rate is solid. The last version 4 of SD ran pretty good on my PC, lighter than Webroot. But version 5 had many issues. PC Tools released what should have been kept in beta.
I actually wouldn't install either. If you can pay for something, I think one of the best programs going right now is DefenseWall. Combine that with SAS (Superantispyware) free for on demand scanning and you have top notch spyware protection.
i agree with the reccomendation of besafe use superantispyware free version as on demand.
in addition to that i would reccomend a alternate browser such as opera of firefox.
i wonder what the current situation of webroot is as well.
since i dont like it no more and i need a good reason to tell my dad so we can ditch it.
my main antispyware app is superantispyware pro
I have some questions for you? What is your present configuration of H/W and S/W. Otherwise all you will get is opinions.
Lighter is hard to define. For me some application that takes 50% of my CPU cycles would be huge or heavy. Other users think that anything more than 1% is heavy.
I don't know what others here have if they use either so that is always an issue when reading or using posts. I did have SpyWare Doctor a year or so ago and with some reluctance switched to SS. I wanted (at the time) the better detection and removal powers it had and the key logger removal features. It's online shield were better. Since then it added an AV which is the not the best around and that weighs it down more! Anyway, on my PC SS 5.3 takes 39,884K and about 0.5% when scan not running. So for me that is not heavy.
Now I understand the doctor has improved a lot. But you wouldn't want to have both. The reason I asked you what you have now security wise is it is possible to have conflicts between packages.
Do you have an AV? What are you using for ASW and a FW now? Are you using a suite?
It's best to design your layered defense carefully based on your surfing habits and to use "weight" only as a tie breaker between equal alternatives.
SS is now the slowest loading item on my PC. But that only happens 1/day so it doesn't matter. Spyware doctor was slow as well but that is dated information.
Why not trial both on you machine but NOT at the same time?
Hope this helps you
For the people who dont know it, a new beta for SS is out (5.5) , with much more improvements
There are lot of other programs that are better and lighter. I have personally used Spysweeper and it slowed my computer too much, but it offered good protection. So if i had to choose between two of them i would go with SS.
I would say that look around in this forum and you will find lots of information about all kinds security programs. Some of them are free so you could save some money. Also you can try almost every program before you buy. End of the day it comes down to what you like and what suites your computer!
i didnt know about that.
but better does that mean better dection aka with more bloat.
or does it mean more features but also light and more stable?
5.5 has alot of improvements to the different shields. I cant compare the stability, because this is a new computer, but it's stable here... no system slowdown, low CPU and lower RAM usage as far as i can see
is it a public beta or a private beta?
if its public can i have a link to sign up?
Hope it's a public beta. Want to check it out
Well, you can sign up here : http://www.webroot.com/beta/beta.php
They have good detection rates but if you use them for anything but on-demand you will grow to despise them. I would recommend SUPERAntiSpyware and AVG Anti-Spyware instead.
If you insist on using Spyware Doctor go download a custom Google Pack and get the free (starter) version.
I used to use SWD 4 but it slowed my machine down. With the release of SWD 5 I tried it again and couldn't be happier. I do agree that its initial release should have been kept in beta though. The forum complaints went down w/ the release of ver186
Separate names with a comma.