Discussion in 'other firewalls' started by ratchet, Aug 5, 2008.
PC Tools FWP is up to version 18.104.22.168. It's not showing up yet via Smart Update. It's not clear from the forum announcement what if anything is different from 22.214.171.124.
Saw this quote in the Forum announcement:
Changes in PCTFW v126.96.36.199 include:
* Remember this setting for multiple popup fixes
* Enhanced Security verification sociability fixes
* Minor bug fixes
Tried and failed !!
I installed it my XP SP3 machine, somehow after mandatory installation reboot the PCT FW+ disappeared !!
I see the process running in task manager, but no icon is sys.tray !! I un-installed and jumped ship back to OA.
Guess, there are still some grey areas .... !!
When you ran the installer, did you choose the "Expert" user mode option? I had the same problem you did. I uninstalled and reinstalled and chose the "Normal" user mode and it installed and ran without a problem. The "Expert" mode can be enabled in the settings menu later. Been running for a few days without issue now.
Thanks, Malcontent. Will try again and let you know
I had the same problem with PCTFW and just did an uninstall.reinstall and everything is fine (running in Normal Mode).
So far, so good.
I was running 188.8.131.52 and having a problem where permissions were not being remember. 184.108.40.206 does fix this so it's a worthwhile update. As of yesterday it was still not available via "smart update" so I downloaded the full installer and did an upgrade over 220.127.116.11.
It is FAILING the normal Leak Test app! Why would that be? It penetrates the firewall and permissions are listed as undetermined.
I've tried for the second time to use this Firewall. Upon installation my Nod icon had disappeared and the system froze, so had to reboot. Is it just me who's pc doesn't like PC tools?!
Piecan, have you gone into the applications tab, and selected 'give full access' to all of Nod's services. And not only give it full connection access, double click on each of Nod's services and enable 'allow' rather than the default 'prompt for permissions'.
See below for example.
The firewall has made a big jump, from single figures to now achieving a 74% rating at Matousec's site. Still a light firewall as well.
Been trying this new version out, and didn't realise it now had application control.
Tried using a portable file explorer to delete some files off the local drive and firewall plus gave the option to permit/deny/always-trust the action.
Those interested in just a pure firewall will probably now prefer rising, but those interested in a firewall with the ability to pass leak tests might now like this one (matousec report at this link).
Hmmm.. something might be wrong with how it's installing on my computer, because other apps besides LeakTest went straight out to the internet. Anyone have that problem, and could you solve it?
@ MVDU: I'm not sure, normally asked me to allow applications, but the new version has the feature to automatically create rules for known programs on it's list, so it might be that (for example, it didn't ask me for programs such as IE or utorrent, automatically allowed them). That can be unchecked if needed in the settings.
Besides, I had to uninstall it since it seems to have some bugs on Vista. While using utorrent, my system just froze and I had to restart. After that it didn't start with windows and I lost my patience and uninstalled it . Now everything runs smoothly again. It's a shame, couse i actually kinda liked this FW, it's very light on resources and neat to use.
Ah well......back to Vista FW for now, if anyone knows what might be the problem I experienced, please let me know.
Enhanced Security Verification ... Was Your Problem!
PC Tools only added Enhanced Security Verification to Version 4 of the firewall.
Enhanced Security Verification - Is turned ON By Default.
PC Tools Firewall Plus Version 3 ... Didn't have Enhanced Security Verification ...
It did have something similar called - Code Injection Protection ( Well Something like that anyway )
Version 3 - Code Injection Protection .... Was - NOT turned on by default.
PC Tools seem to be struggling to figure out what's wrong with Enhanced Security Verification
The problems Enhanced Security Verification can cause - include...
Extremely High CPU Spikes
Over Active Hard Drive
Computer / Program - Freezes
These problems can affect any computer... No Matter how powerful
So For Now... The only thing to do is - Turn.... Enhanced Security Verification - OFF
I've had to turn Enhanced Security Verification - OFF
The Good News Is...
PC Tools Firewall Plus ... Works absolutely fine when - Enhanced Security Verification is switched OFF
Hope This Helps!
http://forum.avast.com/index.php?topic=37991.0 Sorry but Symantec is going to destroy PCTools sooner or later with this move.
I have Enhanced Security Verification (off) as well. Other than that no problems.
I have everything turned on and haven't experienced any problems.
This was mentioned before, but make sure the install is set to 'normal user' rather than 'expert user'. Uninstall and reinstall if you haven't done so.
Expert user can be turned on later, but if installed to be the default, it seems to use more resources (and maybe have more conflicts).
Otherwise, from my experience so far, this firewall seems to be improving.
Thanx for the advice, might just try it out when I get home (I'm at work now, readin' forums 'n' stuff ).
By the way, I had a thought-maybe it happened becouse of peerguardian. Does PG have known problems with PCtools FW?
I Did... Install my PC Tools Firewall Plus as a Normal User.
The problem with Enhanced Security Verification seems to affect - approx 80% - of installations.
Why the other - approx 20% - get away with this problem... Is a mystery!
1/ Maybe it only affects certain computers ( OS / Manufacturer / Hardware ... Dependant )
OR - Maybe...
2/ Not everyone notices there is a problem with the firewall.
It may depend on certain circumstances... As to whether a person notices there's a problem.
* If they have Vista - With CPU gadgets in their Sidebar .... They are Far more likely to notice the problem.
** Someone that uses software a lot ( e.g Games ) - Is far more likely to notice... Than someone that just surfs the web.
Enhanced Security Verification - ON ...
Every time my computer started up - OR - Every time my son played his online game...
My CPU - Intel Core 2 Quad 2.4GHz
Would Hit 100% in all four cores
Enhanced Security Verification - OFF ... PC Tools Firewall Plus - Works just fine
Ok, I tried it for the second time, now with enchanced verification disabled, and it runs smoothly for now. Had one crash of a game during gameplay (Scratches-editors cut) but I think it's not due to the FW. We'll see, maybe this one is a keeper
Thanx for the help!
I unchecked the "automatically allow," and still everything is getting through, even though I click block. Not sure what the problem is, as other firewalls work fine on my computer.
I have v18.104.22.168, smart update doesn't find anything to update.
Can I install v22.214.171.124 over v126.96.36.199 or just over v188.8.131.52?
How will this new version handle the Zemana tests Here?
Separate names with a comma.