MRG - new test results

Did you read this? http://forums.malwareresearchgroup.com/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=390&p=1408#p1408

If that really is how it went down then all onus is on Comodo, in my opinion.

 

Another big mess for Comodo

Though, i like their software

 

I did read MRG side. Even if one side is 100% right, they are both hurting their image IMHO.

Both want respect from the general public. It seems to me they care more about who is right instead of helping improve their product. It reminds me of two kids fighting over something really minor, just to prove their point.

Most professional companies that I have been associated with would not be involved in small issues like this. They would state their point and say how they are going to improve.

I really hope both companies continue improve.

Chuck

 

I have read more at the Comodo forum. I have to agree "It reminds me of two kids fighting over something really minor, just to prove their point." (I was probably involved with something similar the other day, though.)

Melih of Comodo is by far the most childish, in my opinion.

 

The problem with this scenario is where it's all taking place, at the Comodo forums.
Technically its Melih's place where he can do and say what he wants with no retributions, who is going to stop him from posting or close the thread? Any mod over there going to step in and say "O.k. enough this thread is closed"? What they seem to be doing is acting like the loyal followers that they are and letting that childish, immature, thread run it's course.
If that thread was to start say here or another security forum it would have already been locked.

 

I don't care about what Melih says ... I proven it myself ...sorry Comodo fanboys but for real, Comodo sucks bigtime!

 

Now why would you say such things. Comodo doesn't "suck bigtime" as you say. I'm not a fanboy of comodo either. I like what they are doing and its unfortunate that some people are making it look bad. If you do have some solid proof as to why its 'sucks" please let me know.

 

start reading from page 1

 

I have been reading since the thread started. You still haven't given me a concrete answer as to why, in your very small knowledge, that comodo "sucks". Clearly you haven't been around for the discussions of why you can't judge a piece of software on one test. If that was the case then Online Armor sucks too. I would think that alot of people would disagree with that. So please don't throw around comments loosely.

 

You know some people just hate things

And i'm not a exception, but not in the security world, for me here everyone has a chance

 

I thought this https://forums.comodo.com/general-d...e-reason-for-leaving-experience-t55867.0.html was an interesting thread from one of the Comodo mods who used to post here. Sounds like we might see him again-good luck to him.

 

Thanks noob,
I hate to lash out at people but come on....
I'm a die hard a-squared fan and it didn't start trashing it when MRG test had it missing 945 wild results. I've used comodo firewall in ver 3 and it was great. I would use it again, even though these tests say otherwise.

 

Guys cool down, you guys are creating Global Warming here !!

 

Here he steeped in !!

Thanks JR. BTW i don't know why you guys getting so much personal on just a test results? We should take every tests positively. I never take these test seriously, every security product or company can't be 100% right all the time. Always take every test in a positive manner. Why bashing all the time?

Grow up guys !!

 

The problem is not the test, the problem is how the guys at comodo react to the test.

I think Comodo is still a great free product, but they should do less whining...

 

I wasn't bashing anyone. I was defending myself from a personal attack. There is no reason for someone to be coming here and throwing around inaccurate comments. If you can back up your comments with answers then yes by all means comment. To start talking jive and not being able to give someone some reasons in childish.

 

Saying all to me?

I am sorry if i did a mistake....

 

No just commenting in general. I don't want people thinking that I go around causing problems. I like to think that I do contribute positivly to the forum.

 

Sveta, thank you and this should be interesting read!!

 

I can give you several reason why Comodo and Melih suck decieves and cheats folks and show you several threads why! but they have been posted over and over again..just look at the first thread in 'time out room'
bottom of wilders forum!! just for starters

 

Yes I should be very interesting. I had followed one of the links to the comodo forums. Apparently there are 2 mods that were leaving. They sited that comodo wasn't responsive to when they pointed out bugs. They also said that the realeased version that they knew were flawed.

 

Yeah I noticed that too. Decieves is a better way of describing it. Its too bad that they choose to be that way. CIS is a good piece of software. It could be great if it were developed properly.

 

eXPerience dude actually wins
in this, he is free to help others with better
morals and better softwares! I am sure there is not a forum around
that would not welcome him!!

 

Maybe he will find his way over here. Its too bad that they treated him like that.