Free AV Malware Test UPDATED JAN 16 2012

Discussion in 'other anti-virus software' started by narenbisht, Jan 17, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Sevens
    Offline

    Sevens Guest

    Thanks for the test, I'm going to watch for this in the future.:thumb:
  2. Brandonn2010
    Offline

    Brandonn2010 Registered Member

    Updated percentages, rounded to nearest %:

    Comodo - 131/210 - 62%
    Unthreat - 131/210 - 62%
    Avira - 128/210 - 61%

    AVG - 120/210 - 57%

    Avast! - 104/210 - 50%
    Foriclient Lite - 105/210 - 50%

    Panda - 13/31 - 42%
    MSE - 87/210 - 41%
  3. ZeroDay
    Offline

    ZeroDay Registered Member

    Thanks for your time and effort narenbisht :)
  4. bollity
    Offline

    bollity Registered Member

    Disable defense+ of comodo and test again.
  5. Brandonn2010
    Offline

    Brandonn2010 Registered Member

    That was with Def+ ? I'd hate to see its score without.
  6. andyman35
    Offline

    andyman35 Registered Member

    It says Comodo AV rather than CIS,so I'm thinking D+ wasn't used.If it was it'd unfairly skew the results,since the other products aren't full suites.

    Perhaps Naren will confirm this?

    I'm not very familiar with Unthreat,but it appears to be a competent newcomer.
  7. Sevens
    Offline

    Sevens Guest

    To my knowledge Comodo AV does not come with defense+ . I think that packed with the firewall.
  8. Brandonn2010
    Offline

    Brandonn2010 Registered Member

    If it was with just Comodo's AV I've got to give them props for doing this well, especially against 0-day malware.
  9. pbust
    Offline

    pbust AV Expert

    Are you testing signature scanning only? I mean, if the malware is available from a URL (-www.maliciousdomain.com/malware.exe-) are you testing the product during download or only its file-signature component (ie right-click scan)?
  10. ichito
    Offline

    ichito Registered Member

    Some users of forum -safegroup.pl- lead tests of some AV (free and paid)...not all and not always the same AV...latest results of free AV

    18 Jan. 2012
    Avira 2012 - 123/162 (76%)
    KPCD - 84/162 (51,9%)

    16 Jan. 2012
    MSE 2 - 89/152 (58,6%)
    CIS 2012 - 115/152 (75,5 %)
    UnThreat AV free - 119/152 (78,28%)
    KPCD - 100/152 (65,8%)


    15 Jan.2012
    MSE 2 - 75/124 (60,5%)
    KPCD - 106/128 (82,8%)
    Panda Cloud AV - 110/128 (86%)
    AVG 2012 Free - 100/128 (78,13%)

    14 Jan.2012
    CIS 2012 - 109/128 (85,2%)
    KPCD - 106/128 (82,8%)
    -http://forum.safegroup.pl/01-2012-paczki-malware-niebezpieczne-strony-pliki-itp-t5381-120.html

    ------------
    today (19. Jan.)
    KPCD - 126/162 (77,77%)
    Avira - 133/162 (82,1%)
    Last edited: Jan 19, 2012
  11. narenbisht
    Offline

    narenbisht Registered Member

    D+ is disabled.

    I am only testing signatures, heuristics, behaviour blocker, etc. Purely AV test.
  12. narenbisht
    Offline

    narenbisht Registered Member

    This is just a simple RealTime Protection/Detection Test. I download 0-Day malware mainly from MDL, MBL, Malc0de & CleanMX & sometimes I look for other sites for samples. I collect 0-Day malware in a folder & check for the duplicate malware i.e same malware file. First RightClick Scan & remaining are executed to check if they are detected. Hope this is clear.
  13. cruelsister
    Offline

    cruelsister Registered Member

    I think the testers are missing an essential part of Product evaluations. There is the assumption that whatever files are downloaded from the malware link sites are actual malware. This is far from the case! Depending on the day from 15-30% of these files are totally innocuous (keygens, cracks, etc).

    This must be what is going on as the results that they are getting for some products (if indeed tested at default settings) are so far off from the multitude of previous results to make the current test suspect.
  14. narenbisht
    Offline

    narenbisht Registered Member

    Updated Jan 19 2012, checkout 1st post.

    This is the last & final update.

    Hav fun
    Naren
  15. narenbisht
    Offline

    narenbisht Registered Member

    I have already mentioned not a professional test, Just a simple test.

    And atleast Avira & Avast I also tested with All Threats Enabled in Avira & PUP enabled in Avast. The difference was not much, just 1-2 more detections.
    I didn't added this detection in the results.

    But as I said not much difference 1-2 more detection.

    Thanxx
    Naren
  16. Sevens
    Offline

    Sevens Guest

    narenbisht,

    Thanks for your comparison of products. I'll take common everyday testing anytime . It means more to me than over controlled enviroments with what seems over controlled results. Test my product as long as it does well gets old. Along as everybody gets the same pitch lets see what happens.
  17. The Hammer
    Online

    The Hammer Registered Member

    Most of the abreviations I can figure out ichito but what is KPCD?
  18. ALiasEX
    Offline

    ALiasEX Registered Member

    Despite being against posting policy the thread managed to stay alive until the end.
  19. Cloud
    Offline

    Cloud Registered Member

    Kingsoft PC Doctor (KPD/KPCD)
  20. The Hammer
    Online

    The Hammer Registered Member

    Thanks for that.:thumb:
  21. ichito
    Offline

    ichito Registered Member

    Thanks Cloud ;)
  22. pianistaPL
    Offline

    pianistaPL Registered Member

    Panda Cloud AV - 137/162 (84,6%)
  23. pbust
    Offline

    pbust AV Expert

    Naren, can you please PM me the md5 checksums of the files you tested that were "not neutralized"? This would really help us improve the product for everyone else.
  24. narenbisht
    Offline

    narenbisht Registered Member

    Sorry, I deleted the samples as I dont really keep them after testing as for any test I download the fresh samples again.

    But one thing I have noticed, just go to any malware sites & download 30-40 malware samples & test against panda you will find few that are not neutralized.

    The prob may be with panda's cleaning function. Is this prob with other Panda's products too or with PandaCloud only? If only with PandaCloud then why, especially when you have successful cleaning tools in your other products?
  25. fax
    Offline

    fax Registered Member

    May be next time you test you will post also the MD5 otherwise it seems at bit all in the air.... :)

    Thanks,
    Fax
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.