ProSecurity HIPS Owner/Developer Joins Comodo

This was brought to the moderators' attention a couple of days ago, by Melih:

Later from Melih:

Congratulations to the former developer of ProSecurity HIPS, and congratulations to Comodo!

The announcement is here: https://forums.comodo.com/hips_host_...-t25687.0.html

P.S- For those who don't know, CIS= Comodo Internet Security which will be in public beta in a few weeks which will have the up coming CAV 3 & CFP 3 (Including Defense+) Fully integrated.

[Longboard]

That is interesting news.
Melih seems to be holding true to a pattern of benevolence and continued accruing of some serious expertise.
Be interesting to see how this evolves.
Might rock the boat for a few vendors?

[aigle]

That looks interesting.

[Einsturzende]

Great news for Comodo and CFP users

[simmikie]

seems like a potentially good situation for all involved. the former Prosecurity developer can concentrate solely on writing code, and R&D, and not website admin, sales, marketing, licenses, or the public. Defense+ could quickly reach it's next level of refinements, and effectiveness.

i look forward to benefitting from the potential results.


Mike

[Perman]

Originally Posted by Einsturzende

Great news for Comodo and CFP users

Hi, this is true at the first glance and on surface. but the undercurrent is:

The effectiveness of this proven expert and his contribution to Comodo are largely dependent upon how well he can accept and how smoothly he can be absorbed into new corporate culture.

I have seen many cases where brilliant brains are deliberately wasted. Hoping Melih will make this an exception.

Furthermore, the former dev of ProSecurity has morally owed an explanation, perhaps an apology to his loyal fans( including some die-hard followers to this dead date). Evading any of these may seem a norm in modern China ( seldom in ancient China), but in modern Westerners' views, is a big no no.

Now the last chapter of PS, perhaps the final page has become a history. but, some including myself has sour after taste in the mouth.

Buyers beware, always. My grandparents used to say so.

Yep...

As mentored, The ProSecurity Owner/Developer has already contributed to CIS.

[farmerlee]

Originally Posted by Perman

Hi, this is true at the first glance and on surface. but the undercurrent is:

The effectiveness of this proven expert and his contribution to Comodo are largely dependent upon how well he can accept and how smoothly he can be absorbed into new corporate culture.

I have seen many cases where brilliant brains are deliberately wasted. Hoping Melih will make this an exception.

Furthermore, the former dev of ProSecurity has morally owed an explanation, perhaps an apology to his loyal fans( including some die-hard followers to this dead date). Evading any of these may seem a norm in modern China ( seldom in ancient China), but in modern Westerners' views, is a big no no.

Now the last chapter of PS, perhaps the final page has become a history. but, some including myself has sour after taste in the mouth.

Buyers beware, always. My grandparents used to say so.

I too have a bitter taste leftover, i cannot even use the most recent release of PS as the activation does not work anymore, they could at least make it freeware or something.

FYI:

What does that mean for Prosecurity and those who have bought it

Will Comodo take Prosecurity and improve it and offer it free to all owner of Prosecurity as a stand alone HIPS?

Thanks,
Atomas31

we have not acquired the code.

Melih

[nick s]

Originally Posted by 3xist

FYI:

FYI:

Following in the footsteps of some other HIPS developers, Jie has treated his paying customers badly.

Nick

[bellgamin]

Originally Posted by nick s

FYI:

Following in the footsteps of some other HIPS developers, Jie has treated his paying customers badly.

Nick

HOWEVER -- the following NON-free HIPS are treating their customers verrrry GOODLY...

SystemSafetyMonitor
OnlineArmor
Prevx
DefenseWall
A-squared

Maybe there are others -- that's all I can think of off-hand. Can anyone add to the HIPS hall-of-fame?

[starfish_001]

Originally Posted by farmerlee

I too have a bitter taste leftover, i cannot even use the most recent release of PS as the activation does not work anymore, they could at least make it freeware or something.

Exactly a lifetime subscription to a product I can not activate any more. Very poor.

Could have provided an activation fix for paid customers and walked away. To simply walk away without a word is very poor show.

[aigle]

So what about rtdefender?

[Perman]

Originally Posted by aigle

So what about rtdefender?

Hi,

I thought Melih has said that Comodo has NOT acquired PS's codes, and the Dev was trying to sell them, but failed ?

Could the following be true, nothing but true ?.... Comodo's upcoming CIS will NOT have any of PS's components, perhaps just few or more than few traces of his memory ? AND PS from now on will really become a STANDING ALONE product, a homeless orphan ? May GOD bless it !

PS: just learn that HE has a new title in Comodo--Team Leader--HIPS development. Apparently Comodo has approached him to jump onto their wagon for a long while. Never be too late I guess. Great news for future users of CIS--providing CIS is a Freeware.

[bellgamin]

I wonder if HE will be as unreliable and indolent when working for Comodo as he was in supporting paying customers of ProSec.

I also wonder if the eventual goal is to replace Defense+'s code with an updated, Comodo-friendly, re-branded version of Prosecurity. If so, it would be a good idea. Whereas D+ is (at present) a very convoluted HIPS with a GUI that is unfriendly/illogical to configure, ProSec was just the opposite -- that is, PS was both easy & logical to configure.

As for a Comodo suite -- the weak sister at Comodo is now (& has been) their AV. Very poor protection -- too low even to be allowed to be tested. The other AVs from Comodo's same geographic area are QuickHeal & K7 -- both of them weak sisters, also. IMO, their AV is another place where Comodo urgently needs to hire outside talent.

[silver0066]

Originally Posted by bellgamin

I wonder if HE will be as unreliable and indolent when working for Comodo as he was in supporting paying customers of ProSec.

I also wonder if the eventual goal is to replace Defense+'s code with an updated, Comodo-friendly, re-branded version of Prosecurity. If so, it would be a good idea. Whereas D+ is (at present) a very convoluted HIPS with a GUI that is unfriendly/illogical to configure, ProSec was just the opposite -- that is, PS was both easy & logical to configure.

As for a Comodo suite -- the weak sister at Comodo is now (& has been) their AV. Very poor protection -- too low even to be allowed to be tested. The other AVs from Comodo's same geographic area are QuickHeal & K7 -- both of them weak sisters, also. IMO, their AV is another place where Comodo urgently needs to hire outside talent.

I wonder why he would join such an awful company.

Have you ever tried to uninstall their Firewall D+ product? Their forums, for over two years, have several threads of 10 to 20 pages each about the bugs and the inability to uninstall it. I have to reformat my Vista snapshot in order to get it back working. Vista is not worth it to me.

I will stick with XP SP3 and never put another Comodo product on my computers again!!

[doktornotor]

Originally Posted by silver0066

I wonder why he would join such an awful company.

Have you ever tried to uninstall their Firewall D+ product? Their forums, for over two years, have several threads of 10 to 20 pages each about the bugs and the inability to uninstall it. I have to reformat my Vista snapshot in order to get it back working. Vista is not worth it to me.

I will stick with XP SP3 and never put another Comodo product on my computers again!!

I find it particularly amazing how you mention Symantec products in your oooh junk cannot uninstall post @ Comodo forums. I guess you've never used them. A sane person would never mention "Symantec/Norton" and "working uninstall" in the same sentence.

Meanwhile, may I suggest this simple batch to wipe the traces of Comodo on your box, instead of reading the 20 page thread. (You've already been told to do it to which you failed to respond and continued your bashing here, in addition to the above qutoted thread. Very mature.

P.S. CFP uninstall is off-topic here, if you have anything else, move to Comodo forums or create yourself a new thread.

[silver0066]

Originally Posted by doktornotor

I find it particularly amazing how you mention Symantec products in your oooh junk cannot uninstall post @ Comodo forums. I guess you've never used them. A sane person would never mention "Symantec/Norton" and "working uninstall" in the same sentence.

Meanwhile, may I suggest this simple batch to wipe the traces of Comodo on your box, instead of reading the 20 page thread. (You've already been told to do it to which you failed to respond and continued your bashing here, in addition to the above qutoted thread. Very mature.

P.S. CFP uninstall is off-topic here, if you have anything else, move to Comodo forums or create yourself a new thread.

You are way off base. If you would read the forum you would see that I tried ALL of the methods mentioned. I also responded to that.

And, by the way, there are some good uninstallers out there that will completely rid your computer of all Norton products......and if you would try the new Norton NIS 2009 beta, you would see that it's uninstaller works very well. I am not bashing. I am reciting a horrible experience with this company, as have many, many others in their and this community.

These forums are here to inform the users about security products, and if I can help someone from having the same bad experience as many others have had, then I am doing a service, not bashing.

[doktornotor]

Please stop hijacking this thread for off-topic Comodo bashing, your uninstall issues have zero in common with the topic of this thread. Go create your own one which I'll happily ignore.

[LowWaterMark]

Let's all bring this thread back to its proper topic, that being ProSecurity HIPS Owner/Developer Joins Comodo, not anything or everything else about Comodo products.

[The_1337]

Well the good thing is that comodo is free so there's no more worries about ripping off customers.

Well we do know is that Comodo simply hired the developer & Pro Security says bye bye. Who knows what he is going to assigned to? It might not be CFP 3/CIS.

Cheers,
Josh

[Perman]

Hi, I was thinking that..

If Comodo/Melih would have purchased PS by adopting the same White-Knight style to BoClean, paid users and perhaps more and more PC users will be benefited from it.

Simply hiring him implies two things: (1) PS not worth of being saved or being developed further (2) fire sale (deeply cheap type of hiring a talent) style of human resource management.

[Woody777]

He obviously was not making any money with ProSecurity so why develop a product that was of marginal value to him. A new job opens up so why not take it & it offers new opportunities & there you go. I myself really hope that he makes the last version available as freeware somehow. He hasen't so that may mean he might still have plans for it. I am glad that I did not spend money for this application, although it was a great software it was obviously a personal project & not commercially viable.

[alex_s]

Originally Posted by Perman

I have seen many cases where brilliant brains are deliberately wasted. Hoping Melih will make this an exception.

Very true. 9 wemen cannot make a child in one month. And I think the weakest chain here is Melih. He doesn't make an impression of too good manager and clever person.

Though, the whole story is interesting