Discussion in 'privacy technology' started by lucygrl, Dec 3, 2013.
Which do people here think is more anonymous and secure, Liberté Linux or Tails?
I say that because of the gateway-workspace isolation. Based on what Snowden has released, it appears that Tor is most vulnerable through userland exploits. Neither Tails nor Liberté Linux isolate Tor from userland.
Even better would be Qubes, because it isolates more securely.
Also better would be installing Whonix gateway and workstation on separate hardware.
Thankyou, in regards to Whonix Im just starting to look at that now. Am I correct in saying that I need to place Whonix inside a virutual box and that virtual box needs to sit inside a Linux OS? If so, what Linux or Unix would you recommend?
Should I use Qubes?
Also, what do you think of OpenBSD?
Yes, Whonix is a pair of virtual machines, designed to run in VirtualBox.
I like VirtualBox in Linux, and prefer the Debian lineage (including Ubuntu, Xubuntu, Mint, Crunchbang, etc). Ubuntu is a good choice for ones first Linux. But it doesn't matter very much, because you'll be working in VMs. VirtualBox is also available for Windows, but I don't trust Windows as much.
I don't recommend starting with Qubes.
I also don't recommend starting with OpenBSD. Learn Linux first, then the BSDs. You could say the opposite, of course, but you'll have more company in Linux-land. PC-BSD is cool, though
I started with Ubuntu, then switched to Linux Mint based on the Ubuntu stable version. Ill stay with that for the moment till I learn more. After nearly 20 years of windows Im having a few problems with Linux.
Was just thinking, it would be a good idea if someone could put all this together in a package, that is linux, virtual box, whonix, tor, etc and make it available in one simple download. Id even be happy to pay for the convenience. Im guessing because its open source this would be ok, but correct me if im wrong.
Well, that's what Whonix does for Tor. All you need to run Whonix is VirtualBox, which isn't that hard to install. And the OS, of course.
I'm pretty sure that doing all that in a modified installation iso is possible. But it would be very difficult.
Can you please explain about the separate hardware? How to set this up and why?
I don't believe that any known attack would have succeeded against Whonix users. Even though the Whonix workstation would have been compromised, it could not have reached the Internet except through the Tor network, because the Tor client is in a separate Tor gateway VM.
The Whonix gateway and workstation VMs are potentially connected in two ways: 1) through the host machine; and 2) through their shared private network. The first potential connection includes both overt compromise of guest-host isolation, and also side-channel leaks (by modulating CPU load and such). Putting the Whonix gateway and workstation on separate physical machines prevents all of that.
There's still the possibility that adversaries could compromise the Whonix workstation, and then compromise the gateway's firewall. While that risk is unavoidable, it's also common in all networks, so vulnerabilities tend to get identified and patched quickly.
There are instructions at https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Physical_Isolation.
Liberte Linux is much better programmed than WHOINX & TALIS and I trust it more. It is a hardened Gentoo OS with GRsecurity/Pax patches that harden's the OS.
The problem is the Author/Coder is concentrating on mobile app's and not updating Liberte at this moment.
Someone needs to fork Liberte because it's a great LiveCD/OS.
Perhaps, but userland and Tor are still in the same OS. If an adversary roots Liberte through some browser zero-day, what stops them from messing with Tor?
Are you arguing that Liberte isolates browser etc from Tor better than Whonix does?
Mirimir, I have a slight problem with the install. I need to use the pluggable transports bundle, but it does not install this automaticaly, it seems I need do this manually. Can I download that bundle direct into Whonix? Sorry, IM just confused how to do this.
I don't know.
Ask in tor.stackexchange.com
Will the Author be returning to do further work on Liberte? Can Liberte be installed in virtual box?
Thankyou, I sorted it out. Now, im just wondering, after using Ubuntu, then changing to Mint (based on Ubunbtu) , what are the best Linux Systems I should now be looking at in terms of privacy? I read a lot of people say Debian, some say Gentoo and others say Open BSD. I do not have time to try everything, and I do not want to stay with my Mint because I have some doubts about privacy security. What do people recommend?
I find adrelanos' arguments for Debian persuasive.
Thankyou, I will go with Debian, there seems a lot of strong support to use this one.
I notice Liberte use the Epiphany browser, what are the reasons why the developer chose this browser over Firefox?
Separate names with a comma.