av & firewall or suite

Discussion in 'other anti-virus software' started by larryb52, Jan 2, 2008.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. larryb52
    Offline

    larryb52 Registered Member

    Was just curious as to what folks prefer. The suites that emcompass all or the separate parts?, you don't have to add what you use unless you so desire but I just wonder if the companies that have leaned heavily in the area of suites are really capturing folks with that method...thanks
  2. flyrfan111
    Offline

    flyrfan111 Registered Member

    Personally I don't like the idea of suites, I prefer the layered approach. With suites, to me at least, they seem to be much more prone to crashing and then you are totally left in the open. It may take some trials to find programs that work well together and a suite would obviously make that factor a bit easier however.
  3. Bunkhouse Buck
    Offline

    Bunkhouse Buck Registered Member

    Larry,

    I use Comodo 3.0 firewall with defense+ off, Avira Premium, and WinPatrol Plus. They run together smooth as silk, and are only taking about 373mb memory usage with all other processes running. This combination has the least impact on my computer of all combinations I have been willing to test.

    The Avira Suite has a firewall problem, and I won't use it for that reason. Spam control on it is much better than most think, and I won't use ESS because the spam filter is terrible plus some other issues with CPU usage from time to time.

    Maximum protection in my view with minimal use of system resources.
    Last edited: Jan 2, 2008
  4. Antarctica
    Offline

    Antarctica Registered Member

    I tried suites,even had a licence for KIS during one year but now I came back to layered defense and personally I like it better that way
  5. larryb52
    Offline

    larryb52 Registered Member

    AFter a half year of playing with some suites I have returned to av & firewall & comodo I'm still trialing it so far so good...
  6. C.S.J
    Offline

    C.S.J Massive Poster

    simply suites.

    i dont need a firewall so i tend to just buy the AV, but if i were to use one, it would be with a suite.
  7. WSFuser
    Offline

    WSFuser Registered Member

    I prefer separate parts as the av and firewall I like are seldom made by the same company.
  8. midway40
    Offline

    midway40 Registered Member

    I was using suites because I thought the components would work together better. I didn’t factor in if the suite itself would get along well with the OS (as I just learned :( ).
  9. dNor
    Offline

    dNor Registered Member

    Suites :cool:
  10. Niels
    Offline

    Niels Registered Member

    I prefer suite because you know that all features works together without any problems. If you are going to use separate tools you have to think about possible conflicts. I only have 1 security product installed on my computer which is a suite.
  11. Kerodo
    Offline

    Kerodo Registered Member

    Usually I go for separates, but am running McAfee Total Protection 2008 right now and it seems well integrated and runs fine here.. If I find a good suite without issues, I am tempted to use it instead of separates... just seems easier...
  12. JasSolo
    Offline

    JasSolo Registered Member

    Suites for me as well :thumb:
  13. JerryM
    Offline

    JerryM Registered Member

    Suites.
    Jerry
  14. clocks
    Online

    clocks Registered Member

    Only 373k memory? How did you manage that? Comodo 3 alone if 16meg for me.

    I prefer a separate firewall & AV program to a suite. Suites tend to to include features that I do not need or want, and often are more bloated.
  15. C.S.J
    Offline

    C.S.J Massive Poster

    maybe he means 373mb memory, which is alot.

    because 373k is just impossible, each program alone takes up a whole lot more than that.
  16. Diver
    Offline

    Diver Registered Member

    Suites.

    In my experience there are fewer compatibility and set up problems with the suite. Especially for the beginner who does not want to worry if his firewall is keeping his AV from updating. Most of the compatibility issues that I actually see mentioned around here are with additional resident security programs and not the OS or applications. One of my predictions is that the protection and detection strategies of the suites will become more integrated and eventually reach a level of performance that could not be matched by separate components. My definition of performance includes usability and simplicity. A HIPS that goes off when you try to print a document is not going to work on a secretary's machine. Its much easier for a noob to learn a single consistent interface than to mess with multiple geek panels.

    The term layered defenses is an illusion. Its just "mix and match" and hope for the best.

    I suspect that around here preferences are driven by the urge to tinker with security software rather than the goal of reaching decent security with usability. I may not be responsible for 5000 desktops, but if you could not roll it out to such an enterprise, it is likely to be useless except as a hobby item. An exception could be had for anything that would meet the requirements of a large organization but for the lack of centralized management.
  17. Tarq57
    Offline

    Tarq57 Registered Member

    The only suite I've used at home was a Norton one. Bit heavy, bit of a slowdown at times. Very much more involved, and complicated than I thought it should be. I uninstalled it (with difficulty) and have been trying a few separate applications, which I prefer. Have found no conflictions with separate programs, (apart from Zero Spyware, which behaved a bit erratically) but certainly haven't tried all of them!
    Settled on Avast, SpywareTerminator, CFP 2.4, and the MVPS hosts file. Works well.
  18. computer geek
    Offline

    computer geek Registered Member

    Suites, as mentioned, can crash more pronly then left in the open. But if you buy something like kaspersky which has anti-termination and regestry protection, malware is not going to find it easy to shut it down. (kaspersky has very good defense) Also, if the suites components are what they say "tied together" and work seamlessly, it will, not only provide better protection but better resource usage. Edit- meaning that if you get something like norton internet security 2004, its defense and resource usage will be very bad. However, if you get something like kaspersky or ESET(defense is weaker, but works seamlessly) it will overally be better.
  19. risl
    Offline

    risl Registered Member

    I like to have av and fw seperated, used to like suites back in the day when I didn't know much about computers and these programs. Today, don't feel comfortable with any of the present suites. I always find some part of them annoying somehow, some being over protective and telling me that I'll go to hell if I don't enable their antispam, popup blocker or some parental lock. Some just have a good av, but not a firewall that I want or good firewall but av blows. Then I end up picking the ones that meet my criterias. :cool:
  20. s4u
    Offline

    s4u Registered Member

    can't help myself. I just like suites
  21. bigc73542
    Offline

    bigc73542 Retired Moderator

    My opinion is that I believe that the components in a suite probably have a lot better chance of being compatable with each other as where if you use products form different producers there is always a greater chance of incompatability that might not even be apparent at first glance but could have an adverse affect on each of the components ability to performe as it was designed.
  22. RobZee
    Offline

    RobZee Registered Member

    Agree!:thumb:

    Rob
  23. subset
    Offline

    subset Registered Member

    Money makes the suites go round, or is there any free suite o_O

    If you pay for it, you can get a nice package of AV and Firewall plus something against spyware, spam, rootkits etc.

    If you want it for free, there is no choice, you have to arrange your own suite.
    Take an AV (Avira, avast!, AVG...) and a Firewall (Comodo, OA Free, Jetico...) mix it with Anti-Spyware, Anti-Rootkit etc. tools and don't forget to shake or to stir ;)

    Of course it's possible to buy an AV and a separate Firewall, but this seems to be a waste of money and of system resources for me.

    Cheers
  24. Xenophobe
    Offline

    Xenophobe Registered Member

    eEye offers a free suite.
  25. subset
    Offline

    subset Registered Member

    1 year free license only if you are located in the United States or Canada.
    30-day trial for the rest of the world. :eek:

    Cheers
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.