Free AV Malware Test UPDATED JAN 16 2012

[narenbisht]

First Context Menu Scan & remaining malware were executed. ( Free AV's Default Settings ) 7 Products

WIN 7 64 BITS & Latest VMWare

47 Zero-Day Malware (MDL, MBL, Malc0de & CleanMX) JAN 14 2012

1. Comodo AV - 30
2. UnThreat Free - 25 , Forticlient Lite - 25
3. Avira - 23 , AVG - 23
4. MSE - 21
5. Avast - 19

UPDATED JAN 15 2012

35 Zero-Day Malware

1. AVG - 27
2. UnThreat - 24 , Avira - 24
3. Comodo - 21
4. Forticlient - 19
5. MSE - 18
6. Avast - 17

UPDATED JAN 16 2012

60 Zero-Day Malware

UnThreat - 42
Comodo - 41
Avira - 40 , Avast - 40
AVG - 37
Forticlient - 30
MSE - 18

UPDATED JAN 17 2012

31 Zero-Day Malware

Avira - 23
Comodo - 21
UnThreat - 20
MSE - 17
AVG - 16 , Forticlient - 16
Avast - 14

UPDATED JAN 18 2012

25 Zero-Day Malware

UnThreat - 13
Avira - 11
Comodo - 10 , AVG - 10
Avast/PandaCloud/Forticlient/MSE - 9

UPDATE 2 JAN 18 2012

12 Zero-Day Malware

Comodo - 8
UnThreat/Avira/AVG - 7
Forticlient - 6
Avast - 5
MSE/Panda - 4

UPDATED JAN 19 2012 ( Last & Final Update)

60 Zero-Day Malware

Comodo - 46
UnThreat - 43
Avira - 40
AVG - 39
Forticlient - 38
Panda / Avast - 37
MSE - 28

Hav Fun
Naren

Where is Panda Cloud AV?

[Smiggy]

WTG Comodo, still wouldn't trust/touch it with a barge pole though!


>Before any mods jump on my back (again), this is MY opinion and not to encourage 'flaming' or generate argument<

[trjam]

I agree, without Panda these tests say very little as far as the free AV market.

Originally Posted by Smiggy

WTG Comodo, still wouldn't trust/touch it with a barge pole though!

I think Melih from Comodo will contact narenbisht soon ...

[Dark Lord]

Originally Posted by trjam

I agree, without Panda these tests say very little as far as the free AV market.

Yeah without Panda this test looks dry

[Dark Lord]

Originally Posted by tpro

I think Melih from Comodo will contact narenbisht soon ...

Haha yeah

[narenbisht]

Updated Jan 17 2012, checkout 1st post.

Frds, I tried Panda Cloud 1.5.1, the reason I didn't included it coz for many detected threats it said not neutralize & gave online recommendation which I find uncomfortable. For 1-2 threats its fine but 10-12 threats its not good.
So didn't included Panda Cloud. No other AV said cannot quarantine/delete for even 1 detected threat.

Thanxx
Naren

[Noob]

Interesting results thanks for your time dude

[pykko]

Good work for Comodo.

[trjam]

wow, I apologize. Panda has a issue

[JoeBlack40]

Nice job UnThreat

[BoerenkoolMetWorst]

Could you test Avast in the next test with normal and high heuristics sensitivity? I'm curious if it makes a difference, I've had it on high for quite a while, and no FP's so it doesn't seem very aggressive.

[pbust]

Originally Posted by narenbisht

Frds, I tried Panda Cloud 1.5.1, the reason I didn't included it coz for many detected threats it said not neutralize & gave online recommendation which I find uncomfortable. For 1-2 threats its fine but 10-12 threats its not good.

We've fixed some of these disinfection issues already in the beta 1.9.1 and are fixing some more of them before 2.0 release. But if you can send me the md5's of the tested binaries it would help us make sure all the disinfection bugs are fixed.

[Brandonn2010]

Although the number of samples is somewhat small, I'm glad Unthreat is in my top-5 free AVs I recommend.

[Brandonn2010]

Here's percentage blocked for any of you who care:

Comodo - 113/173 - 65%
Unthreat - 111/173 - 64%
Avira - 110/173 - 64%

AVG - 103/173 - 60%

Avast! - 90/173 - 52%
Foriclient Lite - 90/173 - 52%

MSE - 74 - 43%

[Atul88]

Wow top positions keep changing::
But in bottom Avast Rocks..

[Atul88]

Originally Posted by tpro

I think Melih from Comodo will contact narenbisht soon ...

For Avast, they says they are doing maintenance!!
i would say they are on HOLIDAYS!!!

[cruelsister]

To the Testers- Upon reviewing the results that you have posted, I am very curious as to the manner of testing used. The reason for this is that my group has doing extensive evaluations of at least one of the products that are included in your tests [as to evade any accusation of bias I won't name which one(s)], and our results (carried out over 10 months with well over 10,000 samples) is totally at odds with those you present.

If any could provide the Materials and Methods utilized in your test it would be appreciated.

[narenbisht]

Originally Posted by Brandonn2010

Here's percentage blocked for any of you who care:

Comodo - 113/173 - 65%
Unthreat - 111/173 - 64%
Avira - 110/173 - 64%

AVG - 103/173 - 60%

Avast! - 90/173 - 52%
Foriclient Lite - 90/173 - 52%

MSE - 74 - 43%

Thanxx for the %ages Bro.

[narenbisht]

Originally Posted by BoerenkoolMetWorst

Could you test Avast in the next test with normal and high heuristics sensitivity? I'm curious if it makes a difference, I've had it on high for quite a while, and no FP's so it doesn't seem very aggressive.

I like to test defaults as it is used by majority. Currently I am testing with defaults. Later I may test all the products with high settings.

[narenbisht]

Originally Posted by cruelsister

To the Testers- Upon reviewing the results that you have posted, I am very curious as to the manner of testing used. The reason for this is that my group has doing extensive evaluations of at least one of the products that are included in your tests [as to evade any accusation of bias I won't name which one(s)], and our results (carried out over 10 months with well over 10,000 samples) is totally at odds with those you present.

If any could provide the Materials and Methods utilized in your test it would be appreciated.

Heyy,

Few info in my 1st post.

This is just a simple RealTime Protection/Detection Test. I download 0-Day malware mainly from MDL, MBL, Malc0de & CleanMX & sometimes I look for other sites for samples. I collect 0-Day malware in a folder & check for the duplicate malware i.e same malware file. First RightClick Scan & remaining are executed to check if they are detected. Hope this is clear.

Regards
Naren

[narenbisht]

Updated Jan 18 2012, checkout 1st post. PandaCloud 1.5.1 included.

[Dark Lord]

Originally Posted by narenbisht

Updated Jan 18 2012, checkout 1st post. PandaCloud 1.5.1 included.

Hmm... Good work 'Naren' keep it up
And don't forget send the md5's to 'Pbust' to make sure all the disinfection bugs are fixed when Panda Cloud 2.0 is released

Regards,
Dark Lord

[narenbisht]

Update 2 Jan 18 2012, checkout 1st post.