Do I really need a firewall with this setup?

[Engelhardt]

I'm running XP Pro with Antivir PP, the old Boclean and Prevx. This is also behind a Netgear WNPT834 router. Do I need to run a firewall or maybe just the Windows firewall?? Was thinking of just going without to speed things up a bit.

[19monty64]

Pretty much same set-up works for me. Hard to config "light" FW, and the easy ones use to much ram. What started out as convenience has kept me malware-free!!!

[Long View]

If you are able to make a system image - I would keep the Netgear and Antivir and throw the rest out - live dangerously.

If anything bad ever got thru I would simply restore a known clean image. I would trade speed for unnecessary safety every day.

[coldplay]

I'd say no but some guys gonna say yes cuz you need a real deal firewall cuz you want a program running on your machine and you want to deny its outbound traffic.

[what_no_clue]

If you have prevx1 in pro or expert mode, you can get away without a firewall. In expert mode you can also block "known" programs outbound activity, but you can not distinguish between LAN contact & internet contact, it is either blocked or it isn't.

[Engelhardt]

Thanks guys ... so far so good. System sure runs smoother. Running Prevx in pro mode. I really like how easy Prevx is to use. When the Vista version comes out I'm going to have to trial it on one of my Vista machines.

[mata7]

I say not also, I never use firewall or any ASpyware program, only use My Netgear NAT is good enough for me, of course I use a good AV now trying Avira PP and love it so far, Oh and no forget a good backup program

[Engelhardt]

Originally Posted by mata7

Oh and no forget a good backup program

No problem there. I use ATI v10 and am also beta testing Windows Home Server which has automatic nightly backups.