12 virus scanners for Windows in the test!

[Technodrome]

German magazine c't with help from Gega IT Solutions, did extensive antivirus test on 12 products:
AVG anti-virus 6.0
AntiVirPersonal edition
Anti-virus kit 11Professional
Dr. Web
FP Win 5.12
F-Secure
Kaspersky personnel
McAfee virus
CAN 6.0
Norman virus Control 5.12
Norton anti-virus
Panda anti-virus Platinum
PC cillin 2002

Testing technique:
on demand itw
on access itw
Heuristic (3 months old signatures)
Heuristic (6 months old signatures)
archives support (win)
archives support (unix)
mails (on demand and access)
etc

To see full achievement of the each product follow this link(table):
http://216.239.39.120/translate_c?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&langpair=de7Cen&u=http://www.heise.de/ct/02/13/176/tabelle.shtml&prev=/language_tools
(http://216.239.39.120/translate_c?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&langpair=de7Cen&u=http://www.heise.de/ct/02/13/176/tabelle.shtml&prev=/language_tools)

direct(without translation): http://www.heise.de/ct/02/13/176/tabelle.shtml


Technodrome

[JacK]

-{ Quote: " quoting: Technodrome link=board=24;threadid=3158;start=0#21294 date=1029893538]
German magazine c't with help from Gega IT Solutions, did extensive antivirus test on 12 products:
Technodrome
" }-

<<<<<hello Technodrome ;)

http://www.av-test.org/online/sites/os03.php3?js=1&test=2002-01&p=1

Here the last full tests from Andreas Marx (University of Magdeburg and Manager from Gega).

Best regards,

JacK

[Tinribs]

FP-Win 5.12? is this a german only version as mine is 3.12?

[Paul Wilders]

-{ Quote: " quoting: Tinribs link=board=24;threadid=3158;start=0#21331 date=1029916488]
FP-Win 5.12? is this a german only version as mine is 3.12?
" }-

It's the "Pro" version; have a look here (http://www.fp-win.de/produkte/p-fpwin.htm). Coming with a price tag ;)

regards.

paul

[Technodrome]

-{ Quote: " quoting: JacK link=board=24;threadid=3158;start=0#21324 date=1029914589]
<<<<<hello Technodrome ;)

http://www.av-test.org/online/sites/os03.php3?js=1&test=2002-01&p=1

Here the last full tests from Andreas Marx (University of Magdeburg and Manager from Gega).

Best regards,

JacK
" }-

Hi Jack

This one is newer(c't magazine) ! Andreas Marx didn't publish this one yet! ;)


Technodrome

[Technodrome]

-{ Quote: " quoting: Tinribs link=board=24;threadid=3158;start=0#21331 date=1029916488]
FP-Win 5.12? is this a german only version as mine is 3.12?
" }-

FP-Win 5.12 pro is the same as 3.12a(english)! German 3.xx doesnt have 3.12a features! Kind of confusing... ::)


Technodrome

[SKA]

English table too huge for my 17" screen <g>- ne1 can translate summaries as to which AVs came out on top &
on what points ?

Thanks
SKA

[TAG97]

GDATA must be very please. :-X :-X :-X

[Technodrome]

-{ Quote: " quoting: SKA link=board=24;threadid=3158;start=0#21364 date=1029939728]
English table too huge for my 17" screen <g>- ne1 can translate summaries as to which AVs came out on top &
on what points ?

Thanks
SKA

" }-

Scroll it or change your screen resolution...Or wait till http://www.av-test.com publishes results on their site!


Technodrome

[Technodrome]

-{ Quote: " quoting: TAG97 link=board=24;threadid=3158;start=0#21369 date=1029943302]
GDATA must be very please. :-X :-X :-X
" }-

Maybe, but AVK 11 Pro missed some ITW viruses on access! Good Heuristic analyzer is result of using KAV and RAV engines. Both av products developed very good Heuristic analyzer!


Technodrome

[TAG97]

Being a DrWeb user I notice it didn't perform too well in the test :( So I have two questions: Number one is I didn't notice the date of the test. Does anyone know when the test took place? Number two is what version of DrWeb was tested?
Regards
Tim ;)

[Technodrome]

In May 2002!
4.28

Technodrome

[wizard]

I do not like the c't review (a lot of mistakes and misunderstandings in it). After reading the review I had a lot of open questions. The heuristic test from Andreas Marx is IMHO useless. It indicates nothing because:

It is based on the assumption that the av programs are not updated over a certain time but this is an absolute unrealistic approach. And the second thing is that good av programs also update their heuristics to keep on track with new malware and improving detection capabilities. The only thing you can learn from this test is that you have to keep updating your av software but this is not really something new.

wizard

[UNICRON]

-{ Quote: " quoting: wizard link=board=24;threadid=3158;start=0#21479 date=1030017171]

you have to keep updating your av software but this is not really something new.

wizard

" }-


word.

[root]

-{ Quote: "word." }-

Is that your final word? 8)

[controler]

Tried out Anti-virus kit 11Professional today

Not impressed at all. The scan engine is the slowest I have ever seen.
I would not own a program you can't minimize to the tray.
How this one rated so well on AV-Test.Org amazes me...
Now will try some others. Disgusting NOD-32 doesn't have a trial.

[Loki]

Hi controler,

NOD32 has a 30 day trial.

[controler]

Ok I am trying it out ;D
like to see my own scan speed results with all set to default

Thanks Loki

[Technodrome]

-{ Quote: " quoting: controler link=board=24;threadid=3158;start=15#21535 date=1030063910]
Tried out Anti-virus kit 11Professional today
How this one rated so well on AV-Test.Org amazes me...
" }-

By using two top notch engines:
1. Kaspersky
2. RAV

Detection rate counts. ;)


Technodrome

[UNICRON]

just practicing my rapper-slang for "I agree"

Final word? not likely